장기기증 의사표시에 대한 민사적 제문제 = Civil Issues on the Declaration of Intention of Internal Organs Donation
저자명
윤부찬 ( Bu Chan Yoon )
학술지명
과학기술법연구
학술지 이력
연월일
이력구분
이력상세
등재구분
2018
평가예정
계속평가 신청대상(등재유지)
2015-01-01
평가
등재학술지 선정(등재후보2차)
2013-01-01
평가
등재후보 1차 PASS(등재후보1차)
2012-01-01
평가
등재후보학술지 유지(기타)
2011-01-01
평가
등재후보 1차 FAIL(등재후보1차)
2010-01-01
평가
등재후보학술지 유지(등재후보1차)
2009-06-08
학술지명변경
한글명 : 과학기술법연구 외국어명 : 미등록
2008-01-01
평가
등재후보학술지 선정(신규평가)
2007-05-09
학회명변경
한글명 : 과학기술법연구소 -> 과학기술법연구원
학술지 인용정보
기준년도
WOS-KCI 통합IF(2년)
KCI IF(2년)
KCI IF(3년)
2014
0.53
0.53
0.48
KCI IF(4년)
KCI IF(5년)
중심성지수(3년)
즉시성지수
0.43
0.39
0.6
0.13
권호사항
Vol.15 No.1 [2009]
발행처
한남대학교 과학기술법연구소
자료유형
학술저널
수록면
205-246(42쪽)
언어
Korean
발행년도
2009년
KDC
500
등재정보
KCI등재후보
KCI 피인용횟수
1
초록 (Abstract)
In 1999, Internal Organs, etc. Transplant Act was established in Korea. According to the Act, it is possible to take internal organs from the alive, the dead, and the brain-dead. However, the Act has the critical points at civil issues as mentioned be...
In 1999, Internal Organs, etc. Transplant Act was established in Korea. According to the Act, it is possible to take internal organs from the alive, the dead, and the brain-dead. However, the Act has the critical points at civil issues as mentioned below. To begin with, it should be scrutinized regarding minors in civil law. Article 8 of the Act stipulates a minor older than 16 may declare one`s intention to donate internal organs independently, only the case of enucleation the consent shall be obtained from the legal representative. However, letting minor`s declaration of intention be valid without any legal consent infringes the protective ideology of minors. Thus, the Act must be amended as the consent of minor`s legal representative is mandatory for a minor to donate internal organs. The second, the Act does not regard the brain-dead as the dead, in spite of this, regarding the donation of internal organs they are treated as the very same. After one`s death, one`s body comes under the jurisdiction of the bereaved family, then a member of the bereaved family may donate internal organs of the dead person. Even though the Act does not accept the brain-dead as the dead, the family do not meet the hurdle to donate internal organs of the brain-dead person, and the family can declare the intention to refuse the enucleation against the brain-dead person`s advance intention to donation of internal organs. These attitudes of the Act mentioned foregoing should be reexamined because these are not reasonable especially when we think about the civil law system.